Work Permit and Visa Difficulty Ranking: Southeast Asian Countries Compared

Singapore processes an Employment Pass in 3-8 weeks with SGD 330 in government fees and no foreign worker quota for EP-level professionals. Indonesia's RPTKA/ITAS process takes 8-16 weeks, costs USD 3,400-6,200+ per year (including the mandatory USD 1,200 DKP-TKA skills development fund per foreign worker), and requires a named Indonesian counterpart employee for knowledge transfer. Vietnam demands a home-country criminal background check that alone can take 4-8 weeks for some nationalities, plus mandatory degree authentication and health certification, total processing runs 6-12 weeks. Thailand ties every work permit to a specific employer, job title, and work location, requiring a formal amendment for any role change, plus THB 2 million in registered capital per foreign worker. The Philippines layers a DOLE labour market test (proving no qualified Filipino is available) on top of a dual-permit system requiring sequential approval from two separate agencies.

For companies placing expatriate staff across multiple Southeast Asian markets or sponsoring work permits through an Employer of Record, these differences should drive workforce distribution decisions. This ranking scores each country on processing time, total cost, documentation burden, quota restrictions, salary thresholds, and renewal complexity, from Singapore (2/10 difficulty) to Indonesia (9/10), with the specific permits, fees, and constraints that determine whether a foreign hire can start in 3 weeks or 4 months.

Rank 1: Singapore (Easiest)

Governing body: Ministry of Manpower (MOM).

Primary permit: Employment Pass (EP) for professionals earning ≥SGD 5,000/month (SGD 5,500 for financial services).

Factor	Detail
Processing time	3-8 weeks (online via EP Online)
Government fee	SGD 105 (application) + SGD 225 (issuance)
Agent/legal fee	SGD 500-2,000 (optional, many companies file directly)
Quota/ratio	None for EP holders. Quotas apply only to S Pass and Work Permit (lower-skilled) categories
Salary threshold	SGD 5,000 minimum (SGD 5,500 for financial services). Higher for older/more experienced workers under COMPASS points system
COMPASS framework	Points-based complementarity assessment (since September 2023). Evaluates: salary vs. Local benchmarks, qualifications, diversity, skills bonus, and economic criteria
Validity	Up to 2 years (first issuance), up to 3 years (renewals)
Renewal	Online renewal 6 months before expiry. Processing: 3-8 weeks
Dependant Pass	Available for EP holders earning ≥SGD 6,000/month

 

Why Singapore ranks easiest: No quota for EP-level professionals. Fully digital application process. No mandatory medical examination for EP. No requirement for home-country criminal background check (though MOM conducts its own background screening). No language test. Transparent points-based system with published criteria.

Key constraint: The COMPASS framework (Complementarity Assessment) means that EP applications are no longer purely salary-dependent. Companies with low workforce diversity or many EP holders relative to local employees may see rejections despite meeting salary thresholds.

For companies hiring in Singapore through an EOR, the EOR entity sponsors the EP as the legal employer.

Rank 2: Malaysia

Governing body: Immigration Department of Malaysia; Expatriate Services Division (ESD), Ministry of Home Affairs.

Primary permit: Employment Pass (Category I, II, or III).

Factor	Detail
Processing time	2-6 weeks (online via ESD/MYXpats system)
Government fee	RM 200-2,000 (varies by pass category and duration)
Agent/legal fee	RM 3,000-8,000
Quota/ratio	Key posts: 1 expatriate per RM 500,000 paid-up capital. Time posts: subject to MOHA discretion
Salary threshold	Cat I: ≥RM 10,000/month (up to 5 years). Cat II: RM 5,000-9,999 (up to 2 years). Cat III: RM 3,000-4,999 (up to 12 months, restricted sectors)
Validity	1-5 years depending on category
Renewal	Must apply before expiry. Processing similar to new application
Dependant Pass	Available for Cat I and II holders

 

Why Malaysia ranks second: Relatively straightforward online system, no language test, no mandatory skills transfer plan (unlike Indonesia). The quota system is lenient for well-capitalized companies.

Key constraint: The ratio of expatriate positions to paid-up capital means small companies with limited capital face difficulty sponsoring multiple foreign workers. Companies hiring in Malaysia should plan capital structure around hiring needs.

Rank 3: Thailand

Governing body: Department of Employment, Ministry of Labour (work permit); Immigration Bureau (visa).

Primary permit: Work Permit (WP) + Non-Immigrant B Visa (entry visa).

Factor	Detail
Processing time	4-8 weeks (visa + work permit combined)
Government fee	THB 3,000 (3-month WP) to THB 6,000 (1-year WP). Non-B visa: THB 2,000 (single entry)
Agent/legal fee	THB 20,000-50,000
Quota/ratio	4 Thai employees per 1 work permit. Minimum registered capital of THB 2 million per foreign worker
Salary threshold	No universal minimum, but immigration practice requires salary commensurate with the role and nationality. Published minimums range from THB 25,000-50,000/month depending on nationality
Validity	1 year (aligned with visa). Must renew annually
Renewal	Must apply 30 days before expiry. Requires updated employer documentation
Job specificity	Work permit specifies employer, job title, and work location. Any change requires amendment

 

Why Thailand ranks middle: The 4:1 Thai-to-foreign ratio and THB 2 million capital requirement per foreign worker create structural barriers for small offices. Annual renewal is administratively burdensome. The job-specific nature of the permit means role changes require permit amendments with processing delays.

Key constraint: The Foreign Business Act restrictions on business activities compound work permit difficulty, if the company's activity requires a Foreign Business License, the work permit cannot be issued until the FBL is granted.

Companies using an EOR in Thailand must ensure the EOR entity meets the 4:1 ratio for each foreign worker it sponsors.

Rank 4: Philippines

Governing body: Bureau of Immigration (BI); Department of Labour and Employment (DOLE); Bureau of Local Employment (BLE).

Primary permit: Alien Employment Permit (AEP) + 9(g) Pre-arranged Employment Visa.

Factor	Detail
Processing time	4-10 weeks (AEP: 2-4 weeks; 9(g) visa: 4-8 weeks)
Government fee	AEP: PHP 9,000 (1 year) to PHP 18,000 (3 years). 9(g) visa: PHP 8,000 + USD 200-400
Agent/legal fee	PHP 50,000-150,000
Quota/ratio	No fixed ratio, but DOLE evaluates whether the position requires a foreign worker (labour market test). Companies must demonstrate no qualified Filipino is available
Salary threshold	No statutory minimum for AEP, but the salary must be "commensurate with the position" per DOLE guidelines
Validity	AEP: 1-3 years. 9(g) visa: 1-3 years
Renewal	Must apply 60 days before expiry for AEP. Visa renewal through BI
Labour market test	Required, employer must publish the job opening and demonstrate that no qualified Filipino was available

 

Why the Philippines ranks fourth: The labour market test adds unpredictability. DOLE regional offices process AEPs with varying timelines. The dual-permit system (AEP from DOLE + visa from BI) means two separate government agencies must approve sequentially.

Key constraint: PEZA-registered companies (Philippine Economic Zone Authority) have a simplified process and are exempt from AEP requirements for certain positions. Non-PEZA companies face the full process. Companies hiring in the Philippines should consider PEZA registration if planning multiple expatriate positions.

Rank 5: Vietnam

Governing body: Department of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs (DOLISA) at provincial level; Immigration Department under Ministry of Public Security.

Primary permit: Work Permit (Giay phep lao dong) + Temporary Residence Card (TRC).

Factor	Detail
Processing time	6-12 weeks (work permit: 4-8 weeks; TRC: 2-4 weeks after work permit)
Government fee	VND 600,000 (work permit fee)
Agent/legal fee	USD 1,000-3,000
Quota/ratio	Foreign workers cannot exceed a percentage of the company's workforce, companies must submit an annual foreign labour demand report to DOLISA
Salary threshold	No fixed minimum, but salary must be "appropriate to the position"
Criminal background check	Mandatory, must be issued by the competent authority of the worker's home country, apostilled/legalized, and not older than 6 months
Health certificate	Mandatory, issued by a Vietnamese-approved medical facility
Degree authentication	Mandatory, degree must be notarized, legalized/apostilled, and in some cases evaluated by DOLISA
Validity	Maximum 2 years
Renewal	Must apply at least 15 working days before expiry. Requires updated documentation including new criminal background check

 

Why Vietnam ranks fifth: The documentation burden is the heaviest in the region. The criminal background check requirement, which must be from the worker's home country, not country of current residence, creates delays of 4-8 weeks alone for some nationalities. Degree authentication and health certificates add further layers.

The Vietnam work permit guide details the full process. For companies hiring in Vietnam, the annual foreign labour demand report must be filed before any work permit application can proceed, missing this step blocks the entire process.

Rank 6: Indonesia (Hardest)

Governing body: Ministry of Manpower (Kemenaker); Directorate General of Immigration (DGIM).

Primary permit: RPTKA (Expatriate Placement Plan) → ITAS/KITAS (Limited Stay Permit) → IMTA (Work Permit, now integrated into ITAS since Omnibus Law).

Factor	Detail
Processing time	8-16 weeks (RPTKA: 2-4 weeks; ITAS: 4-8 weeks; total with pre-requirements: 8-16 weeks)
Government fee	USD 1,200/year DKP-TKA (skills development fund per foreign worker). RPTKA: IDR 100,000. ITAS: IDR 2,000,000
Agent/legal fee	USD 2,000-5,000
Quota/ratio	RPTKA specifies the number and positions of foreign workers. Must demonstrate knowledge transfer plan (TKA Pendamping. Indonesian counterpart for each foreign worker)
Salary threshold	No statutory minimum, but immigration practice and RPTKA approval require salary appropriate to the role
Language requirement	Mandatory Indonesian language competency development plan (not a test at entry, but employer must provide Bahasa Indonesia training)
Health requirement	Medical certificate required
Validity	ITAS: 6 months to 2 years
Renewal	Must apply before expiry. RPTKA must be current. DKP-TKA must be paid

 

Why Indonesia ranks hardest: The RPTKA approval process requires detailed justification of why a foreign worker is needed, including a knowledge transfer plan with a named Indonesian counterpart employee. The USD 1,200/year DKP-TKA payment is a direct tax on foreign employment that does not exist in other ASEAN countries. Position-specific approval means any role change requires RPTKA amendment.

Key constraint: The Omnibus Law (Job Creation Law No. 6/2023) simplified the permit nomenclature by integrating IMTA into ITAS, but the substantive requirements (RPTKA, DKP-TKA, counterpart) remain unchanged. Companies hiring in Indonesia through an EOR can use the EOR entity's existing RPTKA framework to reduce processing time.

Comparison Table

Factor	Singapore	Malaysia	Thailand	Philippines	Vietnam	Indonesia
Processing time	3-8 weeks	2-6 weeks	4-8 weeks	4-10 weeks	6-12 weeks	8-16 weeks
Total cost (gov + agent)	SGD 830-2,330	RM 3,200-10,000	THB 25,000-56,000	PHP 67,000-168,000	USD 1,600-3,600	USD 3,400-6,200+/yr
Quota/ratio	None (EP)	Capital-based	4:1 + THB 2M	Labour market test	Annual demand report	RPTKA + counterpart
Language test	No	No	No	No	No	Training plan required
Criminal check	No (MOM screens)	Yes	Yes	NBI clearance	Yes (home country)	Yes
Medical exam	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Renewal frequency	2-3 years	1-5 years	Annual	1-3 years	2 years max	6 months-2 years
Difficulty score	2/10	3/10	5/10	6/10	7/10	9/10

 

Strategic Implications

For companies hiring internationally across multiple Southeast Asian countries, the work permit market should influence workforce distribution decisions. Placing expatriate management in Singapore or Malaysia (where permits are fastest and most predictable) and building local teams in Vietnam, Indonesia, and the Philippines (where local hiring avoids work permit complexity entirely) is the most common strategy among multinational employers.

The EOR model is particularly valuable in high-difficulty countries because the EOR entity maintains active RPTKA frameworks (Indonesia), current foreign labour demand reports (Vietnam), and established relationships with processing agencies. This reduces processing time by 30-50% compared to a newly established entity handling the system for the first time.

Companies expanding into the region should map their expatriate needs against these difficulty rankings before committing to a country-level hiring strategy. The difference between 3 weeks (Singapore EP) and 16 weeks (Indonesia RPTKA/ITAS) is not merely administrative, it directly impacts project timelines, client commitments, and competitive positioning.

---

Aniday's HR Services

---